You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
AGENTS.md: list the gate scripts. Add a short list of the scripts in eng/gates/, one line each, saying what each checks, under the existing gates table. Change nothing else.
AGENTS.md, in full; the ## Gates section is the one that changes.
The eight scripts in eng/gates/ and their header comments: adr-shape.sh, adr-text.sh, claude-workflow.sh, commits.sh, no-toolchain.sh, selftest.sh, signatures.sh, smoke.sh.
releases/v0.8.0-preview.3.yaml, docs/traceability/2026-11-06-issue-170-issue-sessions.md and Directory.Build.props (the Version line), for the record's and the descriptor's shape.
The definition was not read for a change: this is a documentation change to AGENTS.md, nothing structural, and nothing under .github/ or eng/gates/ changes.
What I will change, file by file
AGENTS.md: one addition in ## Gates, directly under the table and above the paragraph that starts "selftest plants a failing case". No other line of the file changes. The text:
The scripts in `eng/gates/`:
-`adr-shape.sh` checks that every file in `docs/decisions/` is an ADR of the required shape, with a number no other ADR has.
-`adr-text.sh` checks that ADR-0001 to ADR-0012 equal their sections of the collected file, byte for byte.
-`claude-workflow.sh` checks that `.github/workflows/claude.yml` is the bridge ADR-0014 states, and agrees with the routine's prompt.
-`commits.sh` checks that every commit in a range carries `Refs #N` and a person's `Signed-off-by:`, and names no model.
-`no-toolchain.sh` checks that .NET is the only toolchain in the tree, pinned once, in the root `global.json`.
-`selftest.sh` checks the checks: each passes its clean case and fails every case planted for it.
-`signatures.sh` checks that GitHub reports every commit of a pull request as verified.
-`smoke.sh` checks a published binary's `--version` bytes, its exit codes, and its refusal of a verb.
docs/traceability/2026-11-11-issue-172-gate-scripts.md (new): the session record in the shape of the #170 record: the prompt and its version (1), the tool, what was read, the approved plan, the commits, the checks and their results, and any deviation. Model written "not recorded (ADR-0007 D1)".
releases/: see question 1. My proposal is no new version: the product is unchanged, so Directory.Build.props stays at 0.8.0-preview.3, and I add one line under the summary of releases/v0.8.0-preview.3.yaml, in its AGENTS.md bullet, saying the gates section now lists the scripts. I do not touch accepted-by.
Commits
Each signed as Claude (Emil) <claude+emil@okkels-klein.dk>, with Refs #172 and Signed-off-by: Emil Okkels Klein <emil@okkels-klein.dk>, and no model identifier:
docs: AGENTS.md lists the gate scripts
releases: …, as question 1 is answered (omitted if the answer is "no descriptor change")
dotnet build ProductCli.slnx -c Release and dotnet test -c Release --no-build, only if the answer to question 1 changes Directory.Build.props; otherwise no built file changes and I will say so in the record.
signatures runs on the pull request, since it reads GitHub's verification. Then I open the pull request against main with Refs #172, Approved plan: <this comment's id> and the check results, and link it here.
Questions for Emil
The release descriptor. The issue says "Change nothing else", and AGENTS.md asks for a record and a release descriptor with every pull request. I read "nothing else" as "nothing else in AGENTS.md", so the record is added either way. For the descriptor, which do you want?
(a) Proposed: one line added to releases/v0.8.0-preview.3.yaml, no version change. That descriptor already carries accepted-by, which I leave as it is; say if an accepted descriptor must not be edited.
(b) A new releases/v0.8.0-preview.4.yaml without accepted-by, with Version in Directory.Build.props moved to 0.8.0-preview.4 so product --version matches, and the build, tests and smoke run.
(c) No descriptor change at all, recorded as a deviation in the session record.
The list's order and wording. Alphabetical by file name, as above, rather than the table's job order. smoke.sh is in the list although it has no row of its own in the table (it runs inside aot (<rid>)). Say if you want either changed.
Prompt: eng/routines/issue-session.md, version 1. Started by comment 6792695179, typed by Hafeok by hand on 2026-11-11.
Nothing is implemented yet. That comment starts with @claude but not with @claude approved (it reads "@claude 1. a and 2 is fine approved"), so under the routine's rule it asks for a revised plan and is not an approval. This is the plan of comment 6792653737 with your two answers folded in and no question left open. To approve it, post a comment whose first words are exactly @claude approved.
AGENTS.md, in full; the ## Gates section is the one that changes.
The eight scripts in eng/gates/: adr-shape.sh, adr-text.sh, claude-workflow.sh, commits.sh, no-toolchain.sh, selftest.sh, signatures.sh, smoke.sh.
releases/v0.8.0-preview.3.yaml and docs/traceability/2026-11-06-issue-170-issue-sessions.md, for the descriptor's and the record's shape.
The definition was not read for a change: this is a documentation change to AGENTS.md, nothing structural, and nothing under .github/ or eng/gates/ changes.
Your answers, as I take them
Question 1: (a). No new version. One line is added to releases/v0.8.0-preview.3.yaml; Directory.Build.props stays at 0.8.0-preview.3; the accepted-by already in that descriptor is left exactly as it is.
Question 2: fine as proposed. The list is alphabetical by file name, and smoke.sh is in it.
What I will change, file by file
AGENTS.md: one addition in ## Gates, directly under the table and above the paragraph that starts "selftest plants a failing case". No other line of the file changes. The text:
The scripts in `eng/gates/`:
-`adr-shape.sh` checks that every file in `docs/decisions/` is an ADR of the required shape, with a number no other ADR has.
-`adr-text.sh` checks that ADR-0001 to ADR-0012 equal their sections of the collected file, byte for byte.
-`claude-workflow.sh` checks that `.github/workflows/claude.yml` is the bridge ADR-0014 states, and agrees with the routine's prompt.
-`commits.sh` checks that every commit in a range carries `Refs #N` and a person's `Signed-off-by:`, and names no model.
-`no-toolchain.sh` checks that .NET is the only toolchain in the tree, pinned once, in the root `global.json`.
-`selftest.sh` checks the checks: each passes its clean case and fails every case planted for it.
-`signatures.sh` checks that GitHub reports every commit of a pull request as verified.
-`smoke.sh` checks a published binary's `--version` bytes, its exit codes, and its refusal of a verb.
releases/v0.8.0-preview.3.yaml: one line added under the summary, in its AGENTS.md bullet, saying the gates section now lists the scripts in eng/gates/ (#172). Nothing else in the file changes, accepted-by included.
docs/traceability/2026-11-11-issue-172-gate-scripts.md (new): the session record in the shape of the #170 record: the prompt and its version (1), the tool, what was read, the approved plan, the commits, the checks and their results, and any deviation. Model written "not recorded (ADR-0007 D1)".
Commits
Each signed as Claude (Emil) <claude+emil@okkels-klein.dk>, with Refs #172 and Signed-off-by: Emil Okkels Klein <emil@okkels-klein.dk>, and no model identifier:
docs: AGENTS.md lists the gate scripts
releases: the preview.3 descriptor names the gate-script list
No dotnet build or dotnet test: no built file changes, and the record will say so.
signatures runs on the pull request, since it reads GitHub's verification. Then I open the pull request against main with Refs #172, Approved plan: <this comment's id> and the check results, and link it here.
The approved plan (comment 6792713812) is implemented in #173: #173
Three signed commits: the list in AGENTS.md, one line in releases/v0.8.0-preview.3.yaml, and the session record.
selftest, commits, adr-shape, adr-text, no-toolchain and claude-workflow pass locally on the head, 528a1f8. The build, the tests and signatures run on the pull request.
Activity
Hafeok commentedon Nov 11, 2026
Issue session plan
Prompt:
eng/routines/issue-session.md, version 1. Started by theclaudelabel, applied byHafeokby hand on 2026-11-11.What I read
AGENTS.md, in full; the## Gatessection is the one that changes.eng/gates/and their header comments:adr-shape.sh,adr-text.sh,claude-workflow.sh,commits.sh,no-toolchain.sh,selftest.sh,signatures.sh,smoke.sh.releases/v0.8.0-preview.3.yaml,docs/traceability/2026-11-06-issue-170-issue-sessions.mdandDirectory.Build.props(theVersionline), for the record's and the descriptor's shape.AGENTS.md, nothing structural, and nothing under.github/oreng/gates/changes.What I will change, file by file
AGENTS.md: one addition in## Gates, directly under the table and above the paragraph that starts "selftestplants a failing case". No other line of the file changes. The text:docs/traceability/2026-11-11-issue-172-gate-scripts.md(new): the session record in the shape of the #170 record: the prompt and its version (1), the tool, what was read, the approved plan, the commits, the checks and their results, and any deviation. Model written "not recorded (ADR-0007 D1)".releases/: see question 1. My proposal is no new version: the product is unchanged, soDirectory.Build.propsstays at0.8.0-preview.3, and I add one line under the summary ofreleases/v0.8.0-preview.3.yaml, in itsAGENTS.mdbullet, saying the gates section now lists the scripts. I do not touchaccepted-by.Commits
Each signed as
Claude (Emil) <claude+emil@okkels-klein.dk>, withRefs #172andSigned-off-by: Emil Okkels Klein <emil@okkels-klein.dk>, and no model identifier:docs: AGENTS.md lists the gate scriptsreleases: …, as question 1 is answered (omitted if the answer is "no descriptor change")docs(traceability): the #172 session recordChecks I will run before pushing
eng/gates/selftest.sheng/gates/commits.sh origin/main HEADeng/gates/adr-shape.sh && eng/gates/adr-text.sh && eng/gates/no-toolchain.sh && eng/gates/claude-workflow.shdotnet build ProductCli.slnx -c Releaseanddotnet test -c Release --no-build, only if the answer to question 1 changesDirectory.Build.props; otherwise no built file changes and I will say so in the record.signaturesruns on the pull request, since it reads GitHub's verification. Then I open the pull request againstmainwithRefs #172,Approved plan: <this comment's id>and the check results, and link it here.Questions for Emil
AGENTS.mdasks for a record and a release descriptor with every pull request. I read "nothing else" as "nothing else inAGENTS.md", so the record is added either way. For the descriptor, which do you want?releases/v0.8.0-preview.3.yaml, no version change. That descriptor already carriesaccepted-by, which I leave as it is; say if an accepted descriptor must not be edited.releases/v0.8.0-preview.4.yamlwithoutaccepted-by, withVersioninDirectory.Build.propsmoved to0.8.0-preview.4soproduct --versionmatches, and the build, tests and smoke run.smoke.shis in the list although it has no row of its own in the table (it runs insideaot (<rid>)). Say if you want either changed.Answers: label
Generated by Claude Code
Hafeok commentedon Nov 11, 2026
@claude 1. a and 2 is fine approved
Hafeok commentedon Nov 11, 2026
Issue session plan
Prompt:
eng/routines/issue-session.md, version 1. Started by comment 6792695179, typed byHafeokby hand on 2026-11-11.Nothing is implemented yet. That comment starts with
@claudebut not with@claude approved(it reads "@claude 1. a and 2 is fine approved"), so under the routine's rule it asks for a revised plan and is not an approval. This is the plan of comment 6792653737 with your two answers folded in and no question left open. To approve it, post a comment whose first words are exactly@claude approved.What I read
AGENTS.md, in full; the## Gatessection is the one that changes.eng/gates/:adr-shape.sh,adr-text.sh,claude-workflow.sh,commits.sh,no-toolchain.sh,selftest.sh,signatures.sh,smoke.sh.releases/v0.8.0-preview.3.yamlanddocs/traceability/2026-11-06-issue-170-issue-sessions.md, for the descriptor's and the record's shape.AGENTS.md, nothing structural, and nothing under.github/oreng/gates/changes.Your answers, as I take them
releases/v0.8.0-preview.3.yaml;Directory.Build.propsstays at0.8.0-preview.3; theaccepted-byalready in that descriptor is left exactly as it is.smoke.shis in it.What I will change, file by file
AGENTS.md: one addition in## Gates, directly under the table and above the paragraph that starts "selftestplants a failing case". No other line of the file changes. The text:releases/v0.8.0-preview.3.yaml: one line added under the summary, in itsAGENTS.mdbullet, saying the gates section now lists the scripts ineng/gates/(#172). Nothing else in the file changes,accepted-byincluded.docs/traceability/2026-11-11-issue-172-gate-scripts.md(new): the session record in the shape of the #170 record: the prompt and its version (1), the tool, what was read, the approved plan, the commits, the checks and their results, and any deviation. Model written "not recorded (ADR-0007 D1)".Commits
Each signed as
Claude (Emil) <claude+emil@okkels-klein.dk>, withRefs #172andSigned-off-by: Emil Okkels Klein <emil@okkels-klein.dk>, and no model identifier:docs: AGENTS.md lists the gate scriptsreleases: the preview.3 descriptor names the gate-script listdocs(traceability): the #172 session recordChecks I will run before pushing
eng/gates/selftest.sheng/gates/commits.sh origin/main HEADeng/gates/adr-shape.sh && eng/gates/adr-text.sh && eng/gates/no-toolchain.sh && eng/gates/claude-workflow.shdotnet buildordotnet test: no built file changes, and the record will say so.signaturesruns on the pull request, since it reads GitHub's verification. Then I open the pull request againstmainwithRefs #172,Approved plan: <this comment's id>and the check results, and link it here.Questions for Emil
None.
Answers: comment 6792695179
Generated by Claude Code
Hafeok commentedon Nov 11, 2026
@claude approved
Hafeok commentedon Nov 11, 2026
The approved plan (comment 6792713812) is implemented in #173: #173
AGENTS.md, one line inreleases/v0.8.0-preview.3.yaml, and the session record.selftest,commits,adr-shape,adr-text,no-toolchainandclaude-workflowpass locally on the head,528a1f8. The build, the tests andsignaturesrun on the pull request.Generated by Claude Code
Hafeok commentedon Nov 11, 2026
Landed in 528a1f8 (#173).